Dear Gary Bettman

As you know you have an epidemic of concussions with your players on  hand so the big question shapes up, what spin do you put on it? This is an imaginary conversation so you don’t have to really pay attention, league speak for I’ll defer.

My oldest son, Oriel tried to get into your league- it almost happened. He played three rookie games with the LA Kings. He scored a couple of goals against his peers which is not bad. But then the entire coaching staff got replaced, all that hard work of contacts was erased like a magnetic pulse wiping out a hard drive. But Oriel did get to sit beside Jeremy Roenick for three weeks while with the LA Kings. Did you read Mr Bettman what Mr Roenick has written concerning concussions on Just in case you might have missed it, voila….”We can no longer ignore the stupidity of the hits that are still happening today despite the fact that the players know the concussion aspect is such a big part of the game and sports in general,” Roenick wrote.

“You saw Chris Stewart get suspended for hitting Niklas Kronwall from behind. You saw Andy Sutton get suspended for jumping in the air- a 6-foot-6 and 240 pound defenseman jumping in the air  – to hit Alexei Ponikrovsky. These hits are absolutely unnecessary and the stupidity is beyond belief. Brendan Shanahan probably never thought he would be so busy doling out suspensions because of the lack of intelligence of so many players in very dangerous situations.”

“There are too many hits from behind near the boards. There are too many elbows to the head. There are too many blindside hits. It’s one thing to hit strong and hard, but it’s another thing to throw elbows, have knee-on-knee hits, hits from behind, cross checks on defensemen who are four feet from the boards.”

“I’d like to know when is the respect factor is going to come back into the game.”

Here’s what my son told me last night.

“Dad, I played  six years as a Pro in the minors. I didn’t back away from anything or anyone. But now I would not put my own son into hockey. The concussion issue is simply not going away. It’s just too risky for brain injury. Hockey’s best player, Sidney Crosby is out, Claude Giroux got hit by his own player. That’s 22 players and counting.”

And now it’s Chris Pronger, Captain of the Flyers’ out for the entire season. The hockey headlines scream: Is Sidney Crosby the next Bobby Orr as premature retirement?

Did you know Mr Bettman that registered soccer players in Canada are at one million children, and hockey is now at 300,000 registrations. I don’t think a whole lot of parents will be choosing hockey until something massive is done to reduce concussions. So the situation may self regulate within a generation. There will be no more draft-able high-caliber players to choose from for populating your league.

My best advice for improving the protection of player’s brains is what I have already mentioned in a  previous blog. Race drivers can walk away from a 20G deceleration crash without a serious concussion like Flyers’, Claude Giroux just recently experienced with a knee to the head by his own player, Wayne Simmonds trying to jump over him. How can that be? How can a driver have a vehicle crumple around him or shred his composite frame structure, yet he is relatively unscathed?  How do these drivers do it?

It’s their H.A.N.S. device. The head loading after impact deceleration is restricted into non rotation plus the device channels the collision energy into their entire torso, massive enough to withstand and dissipate their collision energy. The drivers also have the option of the HUTCHENS device, a bunch of head  straps attached to their lower torso, around the pelvis, that perform a similar torso loading away from a head impact.

What does a head and neck restraint do?
Trevor Ashline’s Hutchens Device is designed to do one thing, share the load with  the neck in an impact.  This is accomplished by restraining the driver early in the impact, limiting the severity of the load the driver sees and riding it out until the impact is over.  Ashline explains, “the pelvis is better equipped to handle g-forces than the rest of your body.  For this reason, it is critical to lock the pelvis down with the lap belt.  When properly locked down, the lap belt has a load of 2,500 to 3,000 pounds on it.  For this reason we use the seat belt buckle assembly as the anchor for the Hutchens Device.  From there heavy straps, with low elongation webbing, run up the drivers back where they attach to the helmet.”

Now, during an impact, as the head begins moving forward the straps running up your back tighten up.  The upper torso starts moving forward because your pelvis is locked down.  This begins involving the lap belt, which is under 2,500 to 3,000 pounds of load.  As a result the straps running up your back that are attached to your helmet tighten, greatly reducing the amount of load your upper neck sees.  Ashline continues, “If you wait and restrain late in an impact, you see a huge spike in the load on the neck.  The Hutchen’s Device, when used properly, begins restraining early so you never see the high load numbers that you would without one.”

How is it Installed
Installation of the Hutchens Device begins by attaching either a single or optional double hook attachment to your helmet.  This requires you to drill either one or two holes on each side of the helmet.  The Hutchen’s Device then has leg straps and a waist strap that must be fitted to the driver.  A tether strap then runs between the driver’s legs and attaches into the existing seat belt latch.  Tethers then run from the Hutchens Device up to the hooks you’ve installed on the helmet.  The D-Cel is similar to the Hutchens Device, except it doesn’t tie into the seat belts.  It relies on the driver’s pelvis for anchoring.  As a result, the driver has no attachment into the seat belt system with the D-Cel.  For a better understanding of the installation of the Hutchens Device and the D-Cel visit their manufacturer at  The site allows you to download the actual installation directions.

(Sourced from newsletter, Head and Neck Restraints 101 Hutchens Device D-Cel)

So the other big question of course involves money. What about the fans? But at this point the question is way above what the owners want or demand, what the fans want or demand. Now it’s all about the players. How best to protect them? They are at the source of your money generation.

Somehow considering your past behavior I am not too optimistic about you making a great decision toward protecting the players-protecting the game. I’m not sure you can see the tipping point of the league’s survival is now in the pivot frame. No enterprise yet in human existence is permanent, absolutely none. Any tradition can stop in the beat of the heart.

There’s much more of course. Make the ice surface larger, Olympic size, enforce mandatory reduction of the hardness of all of the hockey equipment. Mandatory full head protection with a new Hutchens Device specially designed for hockey is all possible. Or return to minimal equipment. That way every hit has consequences instead of deflections, now it’s true contact. It will reintroduce  Roenick’s respect, since a heavy hit will have  repercussion back onto  the hitter.

Otherwise this is the beginning of the end, no question.

Good Luck!

P.S. Here’s the latest Simpson Safety Equipment Head and Neck support device also devised by Trevor Ashline, looks like it could be adapted to a set of shoulder pads, no?   The clock is ticking…….                                                                                           

About cerebrovortex

Montreal Grandmother, Agnes Kent was saved by Raul Wallenberg from certain death, when he provided papers for her and her Mom to escape away from the Nazis. Today when asked what that escape meant, she replied,"Remind people, that while statesmen and whole countries remained silent and did nothing, a single individual chose to act, with ramifications that proved enormous. Similar choices confront us today. Write that simple truth she said, it can never be repeated often enough because the world keeps forgetting it."
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Dear Gary Bettman

  1. Sam says:

    Well put Micha, I think you should forward this to paul arcand on 98.5! This is a hot topic and you present some very compelling arguments


Comments are closed.